Yes...Astro-not went first (getting the LOWEST total vote).."singing for the save" were Drew & Marcus.
Personally I think Drew has the better voice...Marcus the better stage presence, however BOTH would have gone eventually they have been in the bottom two before so obviously America just wasn't feelin' it with these two.
I agree with the thought that Simon (knowing the industry and knowing what his "client" can and can not do) DIDN'T let her sing an "up tempo" song because she just couldn't pull it off. Better to send her off with him taking the fall as opposed to her not being up to snuff (at least in his small mind).
Marcus will end up in bottom two again, L.A.Reid is trying to make this kid into the second coming of Bobby Brown..hey L.A....Bobby Brown didn't work so well the first time around...just sayin! Rachel needs to sign that darn Disney contract and move onto better things, Chris Rene will enjoy his time on this show and hopefully someone will allow him to WRITE..that is where his talent lies.....as for the Melanie and Josh...whoever said THEY NEED THIS SHOW hit the nail on the head...hopefully they can parlay this into something lucrative..may not become "superstars"...but hey what do I know...I'm just stuck here in my "normal" life and watchin' this guilty pleasure on my big arse tv!
I'm happy with the remaining contestants. I'm not fans of Chris or Marcus, but they are nice guys with a good attitude. I love Josh, Melanie and Rachel. It's a win win from here on out IMO.
I agree with you...the two I didn't like are both gone. Marcus and hopefully Chris will go next week, leaving us with the three I do like. Isn't it amazing that Simon did not take Melanie at first in favor of two POP PRINCESSES . It was only after hearing his fellow mentors tell him he made a mistake did he bring her to the show...yep Simon you made more than one mistake this season LOL
I never did understand his desire for Drew. I know she has many fans here and I have read elsewhere that she had many fans. I never understood it. I don't know how how she ever got as far as she did. Perhaps a Taylor Swift thing. ???
Now, if Simon will let Rachel do songs that are right for her, she can stay at the top. It's like him giving Melanie, The Greatest Love of All to sing and then Rachael gets, Row, Row, Row Your Boat. Please Simon.
She sang the song very well... but it was too strange having a 14 year old girl singing a song which is about denying an accusation of fathering a baby.
Bottom line: Simon's song choice sucked.
Hopefully, he'll make up for it by getting her a record deal.
I agree with those who said if looks could kill that the other judges would be in trouble... at least he was smart when he declined to make a comment (even when the host continued to pressure him to do so).
Unsure why Rachel is still here... she isn't that great of a singer... and I don't think she will sell many records. She WILL be amazing when Disney signs her - hopefully for a tv or movie deal!
Last edited by jmb; 12-02-2011 at 01:10 PM.
I do like Marcus, but as an entertainer. Drew had a much better voice, but at least Marcus kept me awake. I thought he did much better than Drew in the sing-off and so deserved to remain.Marcus pulled off his best performance tonight no doubt. He deserved to be spared. And I say this as someone who has not once been a Marcus-fan.
Amen. He may have a career or not, but I won't spend money on him.Astro? Glad to see him go. VERY glad.
Somebody here compared Drew to Pia once. Brother, after this week, I totally got it. Lovely voice, but both of her songs were snooze-fests. I agree with whoever said that Simon might sign her up, but that she might not necessarily have a big career. Honestly, I wouldn't spend money on her, either.Drew? One trick pony who overstayed her welcome. Sure, Simon has been stubborn in not mixing it up for her... there's no doubt about that but someone mentioned that he realizes she cannot pull off an uptempo song so he kept her from them. Maybe that was a smart tactic on his part, I dunno... all I do know is that I gotta tell ya, every.single.song she performed sounded exactly the same. EGG-ZACT-LEE.
That's what I thought. While the host was reading off the results, Rachel was smiling at her fans like she was happy no matter what (Marcus did the same). I thought that was really cool. She's one of those rare kids who's self-possessed enough to handle the hard knocks of life. I still don't like listening to her, though, because it's just too weird hearing a child belt out adult songs. Agree that she needs to shuttle over to Disney.After seeing Astro's outburst when he was in the bottom 2 (or was it 3??) and Drew's reaction tonight just proves the point that these are children and completely... completely... unprepared to handle the inevitable disappointments of this show. Granted older teens and even adults can lose it but they need a bottom-end age limit so we're not subjected to these kinds of "sore loser" outbursts. Something tells me Rachel Crow has it more together and would take it so much better than Astro and/or Drew.
That's what I'm seeing. Only question is who will join them in the finale. Chris might since he has a sympathetic backstory, or it could be Rachel since she's so cute. I would be very surprised if either of them won, but hey, weirder things have happened on these shows.F2... Josh and Melanie.
And speaking of hosts, I've thought Steve was a wooden stick since day one. However, I also can't stand Ryan Seacrud's antics, either. I thought Carson Daly on The Voice hit it just right: sympathetic and friendly to the contestants but not over-the-top. I hope they keep him when that show comes around again.
Maggie: "While she takes care of the men with the guns, why don't you sit down and I'll make you a nice, hot cup of tea?"
Pan Am stewardesses: prepared for anything!
Melanie could be marketable, but it's risky. In todays market, Drew and Chris have the best chances at making hits. Unfortunately, the people voting on singing contests aren't necessarily the one's buying records. My boys have their Ipods and buy songs, they can't stand and won't watch AI; they do like X Factor and both wanted Drew to win. They also love Chris.
Speaking of Chris, I don't think it's his back story that is bringing him the votes. I love when he sings his own songs .. he shines. He definately doesn't cover songs well, except I thought he did the best cover of Michael Jackson even with his limited range. My mother even thought he was the best of the night and she's 82! He has something special. Paula said 10 million people have downloaded Homey. LA should let him sing his own songs like he did with Astro.