Rachel is cute and can sing but I really would prefer to see her in a Disney Classic Movie... Really at 12 or 13 what does a girl her age sing about that would appeal to the masses?? I just don't see it happening yet for her. She was the worst of the night (in my book) along with Marcus but he really is the most entertaining to watch. I love Drew's voice but I don't think the girl has a chance with so much controversy surrounding her ever week (such a shame really) I think the whole Melanie "come back" story was to drum up fans and votes only. Because honestly, how could she not have been in Simon's top 4 to begin with??
Paula's really the only one of the judges that I can seem to stomach... for the rest it doesn't seem to be about the best talent but more about which "mentor" will win.