I'm glad Simon brought back Melanie, but that's who he should've chosen over Tiah. Simone wasn't that great either. The Anser was way better than the new girl goup Paula picked. I was glad she chose the Brewer Boys though. I'm not too sure L.A. Reid made a good choice on that 14 year old kid. I would've vote for him. He needs to mature as an artist and person first. Didn't Mr Reid comment on the boy's attitude as well?