11/14/12 Show Discussion Thread

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by JavaJo

How the hell is Cece still there when Lyric145 and Jennel is not? Baffling.

---

I know, how odd is that? I think she got the pity vote. I think it's a pity Lyric has gone- and not her

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by jammyjoe

So why didn't they do the double elimination last week? Kinda not fair that Janell went home as only Lyric 145 should have just gone home this week and Cece should have been gone home last week if they had this double elimination. I just couldn't bear to watch Cece perform again and I can't believe she went up 7 places! Yea I get that she got the pimp spot and Janelle got the death spot. Looks like it's Tate's game to lose and Carly Rose can't seem too break his hold. I think top 3 for the whole series will be Tate, Carly Rose and Emblem 3. Those country voters are intense voters as everyone has realized when the last two finalists from American Idol the year before were country singers.

---

They brought Diamond back and had to eliminate 2 to stay on schedule with an extra person.

Someone should produce a competition for country singers only and leave this one and AI to future pop or rock singers.

I really like the format of this show but my enjoyment spiraled down as Tate took #1 again.

Note to judges, harsh criticism only rallies viewer sympathy votes. Keep yourselves in check!

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Shoepie

Someone should produce a competition for country singers only and leave this one and AI to future pop or rock singers.

---

Good idea. I thought someone came up with that concept a few years ago, and nothing happened. I am not sold Tate will win the whole thing. jmho

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Fanny Mare

Good idea. I thought someone came up with that concept a few years ago, and nothing happened. I am not sold Tate will win the whole thing. jmho

---

Peaking too soon can be a problem so he may not.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Shoepie

They brought Diamond back and had to eliminate 2 to stay on schedule with an extra person.

---

I know, that was obvious. In fact I thought there will be dbl elimination last week. My question was why didn't they do it last week when they needed to eliminate two?

I thought Cece and Arin will be gone but maybe next week.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Fanny Mare

Good idea. I thought someone came up with that concept a few years ago, and nothing happened. I am not sold Tate will win the whole thing. jmho

---

It's the United Tate of America! So he will win just like Scotty McReery did on American Idol. Not the best singer but a lot of dedicated country fans who will vote up into the wee hours of hte morning.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Shoepie

Someone should produce a competition for country singers only and leave this one and AI to future pop or rock singers.

---

There was a country version of AI called "Nashville Star" :). It aired for 6 seasons on USA and NBC channels.
It was a sad, sad day when this show got cancelled :(.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by jammyjoe

It's the United Tate of America! So he will win just like Scotty McReery did on American Idol. Not the best singer but a lot of dedicated country fans who will vote up into the wee hours of hte morning.

---

We'll see. I dont think so.

Country fans are the ones that can afford to stay up all night voting for their Hero.

CeCe got pity vote? They find every reason to give a pity vote now.