11/1/12 Show Discussion Thread

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Bet2Win

I'm surprised as well. Simon was so critical of anyone on AI that tried to take on a Whitney Houston song ... yet he had last year's winner sing several Houston songs. :mmm

---

He is better with the groups.

I think Carly has a good chance of winning and the other girl with the raspy voice. I love talent. :)

I wonder if Simon regrets letting Sister C go in the light of Tate being #1. Certainly they would have split the vote.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Fanny Mare

One direction are a huge hit in the UK. Huge. So possibly he would do it in the US But heck he already has Il Divo, they are his as well :up

---

They are a huge hit in the US too. Especially with the girls lol.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by mesachick

They are a huge hit in the US too. Especially with the girls lol.

---

My eldest granddaughter loves them.

I, as a near 20-year-old male, think they're ok. :lol But really it's not my style.