9/19 Show Discussion Thread **spoilers**

[Fanny Mare]

I agree, hat girl wasn't that good( pitchy) compared with those that went before her. Maybe this will teach her not to be quite so cocky, although Simon has always liked someone that challenges them all

[JohnnyK]

Catching up on yesterday.

Changyi <333 She wasn't good but at least she was able to go as high as needed during certain parts of the song.

[JohnnyK]

Austin barely opens his mouth and the girls start screaming. I guess we found our fan favorite.

[Fanny Mare]

Maybe. He was kind of cute. The guy in the wheelchair( Freddy ) gave me chills when he sang , chills. I can't imagine what he would be like if he lost more weight.

[Shoepie]

Last night since there is no thread:

I loved Simon's reaction when they all put the little girl in pigtails through! I shared his horror. She will not make it further; soft hearts prevailed sensing rejection may cause her too much harm. There is something very weird about this child. And her family and friends. Very odd that so many came to the show.

Wheelchair man did not impress me.

I am looking forward to the next phase. I much prefer this to Idol and Voice.

[Shoepie]

Maybe. He was kind of cute. The guy in the wheelchair( Freddy ) gave me chills when he sang , chills. I can't imagine what he would be like if he lost more weight.

I was thinking about the surgery he needs now and in the future to remove excess skin. Terrible, I know, but I could not get my mind off of that.

[Fanny Mare]

I was thinking about the surgery he needs now and in the future to remove excess skin. Terrible, I know, but I could not get my mind off of that.

And how he would be able to sing, and take deeper breaths if he was smaller. I don't know how he got to be 900 pounds and lost what, 400 pounds? How did he do that? All that went through my mind, and yet his singing still gave me chills.

[Shoepie]

And how he would be able to sing, and take deeper breaths if he was smaller. I don't know how he got to be 900 pounds and lost what, 400 pounds? How did he do that? All that went through my mind, and yet his singing still gave me chills.

He was probably hospitalized and on a liquid diet like Optifast.

[JohnnyK]

He said through diet and exercise, right? Not to be mean, but... how can someone that's 900 pounds exercise?

Bootcamp starts next week.

[xmaskat]

He said through diet and exercise, right? Not to be mean, but... how can someone that's 900 pounds exercise?

Bootcamp starts next week.

That is amazing that he was able to drop 400+ pounds! Good for him.

He could use 10 lb free weights to exercise the upper body & arms, and get a pedal exerciser for the lower body. These could be used while in his wheelchair.