I'm thinking Mykie's going to take it, hands down. She has poise and confidence, and while everyone else was running around like crazy, not knowing what to do last minute - she focused and concentrated on what she was doing and got it done, and got it done right. I also see in her the ability to divert her guest's attention toward the good and away from the bad.
Although I haven't seen her handiwork - she's obviously creative. She might be able to give Martha a run for her money when it comes to a "how many ways can you decorate a pinecone" contest.
I don't like her, personally, but I think she's the best man for the job.