2/14 Show Discussion **Spoilers**

[ClosetRTWatcher]

...The judges are sour with everyone, there is no levity or sense of fun...

I completely agree. I am a big fan of Project Runway and Top Chef, so I really had high hopes for this show but so far it is a big disappointment. I think the comments about editing are right on - show us some of the positives! All the negatives just make the judges look snooty and, well, judgemental. I want to see these contestants get constructive criticism, but there has been nothing contructive in what the editors are showing us.

[Dogbat]

I completely agree. I am a big fan of Project Runway and Top Chef, so I really had high hopes for this show but so far it is a big disappointment. I think the comments about editing are right on - show us some of the positives! All the negatives just make the judges look snooty and, well, judgemental. I want to see these contestants get constructive criticism, but there has been nothing contructive in what the editors are showing us.

This is one show where reading the blogs is necessary. The judges don't like the editing either.