Elia was just plain immature and naive. She couldn't read the situation: Andy Cohen is sitting there, and while "host" Andy may have wanted the juicy drama for the show, there is no way that "Senior VP of Bravo" Andy is going to let someone dirty the reputation of one of his signature stars while he is sitting there. And there really is no way for Elia not to look as if she was reacting from bitterness. Her tone was angry and accusatory, and she has no place to be talking to Tom like that. Andy should have been smarter about introducing this topic, or maybe shouldn't have brought it up at all. But still, Elia did nothing to convince me that this wasn't all sour grapes from this season, and even her season, since I think she still carries a grudge about that too. Even then, she was constantly disagreeing with the judges, not because they were wrong in their beliefs, but because she thought that their palettes were inferior to hers. She never should have gone on TV in the first place, in my opinion.