I kind of disagree. I do want to see someone win who has great talent. But things like management, serving, and playing DO ammeter. It is top CHEF and not top cook. They're looking for someone great who can achieve greatness with their own restaurant. Remember when the show started the prize money was considered seed money to open a restaurant. Compare Stefan's waiter skills to past winners like Stephanie or Richard. They understood the hospitality end and the management end in addition to making great dishes. I'm not saying Josie will win because she has these skills. She's affirming why she didn't win the first time. But others are lacking in these skills too. As long as they are all weeded out by the end, I think the show is focused on the right things.