Colton, if you need a HII this early in the game you're in serious trouble.
If anything, he seems to have alienated himself from the men tribe.
The theft thing was pretty stupid. As was the women who caught the chickens and then tried to "barter". Only to get BURNED (pun intended) when they couldnt make a fire. LOL.
These men vs women things always seem to turn into Women feeling like they have something to prove (which usually galvanizes them as a tribe) while the guys are busy scheming on eachother.