I couldn't agree more Jodaar. I wanted Colby to win, he didn't. I wanted Danielle to win, she didn't, for those very reasons.
The problem with having the other contestants pick the winner is that sometimes, as in the case of S2 and BB3, you get people that can't stand that someone else played the game better than them, so they allow personal feelings to get in the way.
I've also mentionned this in another thread, but I hate that the winner of the last immunity challenge selects who they want to come with them to the F2. Then it's all about who they think they can beat rather than the best 2 players.
Jason and Kathy got SCREWED.