I agree that he needs an idol or immunity to remain there. I think that Reynold and Eddie are tight enough to vote Malcolm out, if they're presented with the offer of saving themselves. Malcolm will not be trusted by anyone now that they know he kept an idol secret. Almost everyone will be gunning for him at the next TC, if he doesn't have immunity.
Last edited by MsFaninNJ; 04-18-2013 at 07:34 PM.
I believe that they wanted her out, if they couldn't vote for the three outcasts (if you will). Even before Phillip and Sherri, they wanted to get rid of Andrea. Some may feel that she's sort of running things, and that she can't be trusted with all the hanging out she does with Eddie, Reynold and Malcolm. She may be seen as being in the similar position that Corrine was in, having a secondary alliance.
Brilliant move from Malcolm.
Survivor: Caramoan - The Extra Immunity - YouTube
What Malcolm should have done is to not reveal his 2nd HII. After the votes were cast, he should have told Reynold to give his immunity necklace to Eddie. That way, he didn't have to use his 2nd HII and reveal it. I don't know if Reynold would agree to that a 2nd time but if he is smart, he should because it is not likely that they will vote for him for having the II. Parvati did this before so it's not unprecedented.
I wish Malcolm won the IC because then he can make this kind of move. After the votes have been cast, he would give his II to Reynold and the 1st HII to Eddie, rendering all three safe from votes while keeping his 2nd HII hidden. Now all they had to do is look for the HII again and win IC. Rinse and repeat!
I was thinking that they have to give up the necklace BEFORE the vote, while Jeff asks for the idols AFTER the vote.