Using only contestants from PI (since they only had one person from before) and after:
Andrew (PI) Even Jiffy said the Outcast twist cost the season a great player in Andrew.
Brady (Vanuatu) Fat chance he'd be brought back but he deserved to go so much farther over Chris, who helped his tribe lose practically every challenge
JP (Vanuatu) See above, and I resented Travis's remark that he deserved to go because he didn't have kids, therefore didn't need the money
Rory (Vanuatu) I just love the comment he made about wanting to burn the camp down And it should have been one of the other fat five first over him
Tom (Palau) The real king. And even if I liked Terry I'd still say Tom could take him.
Jonathan (Palau) I'd just like to see him get a chance at the game.
Bobby Jon (Palau/Guatemala) My favorite Survivor eye candy, though I doubt he'd be asked back a third time.
Brandon (Guatemala) Just loved the guy, and he was just unlucky that he got the short end of the stick.
Aras/Austin (Exile Island) Need someone from that season.
Eliza (Vanuatu) Not the most popular but I liked her.
Jolanda (Palau) Didn't start off on the right foot with her tribe but I still think she deserved to go farther over Ashlee (who quit the following episode), Jeff (even without his injury didn't seem to be much of an asset), Kim (useless), Ibreham (see Jeff)
Angie (Palau) Would have been safe if Ib didn't have the immunity from Koror
Danni (Guatemala) My favorite winner ever
Margaret (Guatemala) Once again a tribe switch screws it up for someone that looks like their in it for the long haul.
Misty (Exile Island) One of my only real favorites from that season, and I think she would have fared much better on another one.
Cirie (Exile Island) I never would have expected her to make it as far as she did. It's obvious Cirie loved the experience and probably grew more than any other Survivor contestant. I loved her sense of humor and while many may call it a cackle I love her giggle.
Sally (Exile Island) I never thought there'd be three women I'd want to see from Exile. I think Sally was more kick a@@ and had more potential than came across. I'd love to see her get a second shot.