I feel like I'm the only one who still likes Penner, lol. I do agree that he probably shouldn't come back, four times is too much. Even three times is too much, I think Penner was the only player who deserved to play three times, and that's only because of what happened his second season. Absolutley, just give us some seasons with all new players CBS! If they have to bring players back, I'd rather it be medevacs and/or some of the more interesting people who were voted out early instead of "Favorites" or "All Stars"