9/14/11 Show discussion---Spoilers if you didn't see the show yet

[PWS]

, Tilden. Way to go, doggie!
People keep telling Semhar she's ok. I'm hoping they are lying...she won't be on the jury, why not lie and avoid the scene at camp, since she seems like a scene maker. And she's unlikely to be a Redemption Island threat to stay.

[dagwood]

So far I am loving Rick. I feel bad for coach, though. His team was visibly not pleased with him. Watch it be like Heroes V Villians where I feel sorry for him and root for him.

[PWS]

Elyse is the one who was so good with the machete, teaching Cochran how to open a coconut.

[PWS]

WOwl... I thought papa bear (the detective) was on Cochran's side.

[PWS]

Semhar goes to Redemption Island ... Ozzy says, I should have taught her to make a fire.
Let's see how many votes Cochran got.

[Tilden]

Glad they voted out Semhar. From a tribal viewpoint, it made sense. Cochoran may not be a particularly strong player either, but so far, he hasn't caused a confrontation at camp, which Semhar did. And after Rob and his adoring minions last year, I'd think anyone on Ozzie's tribe who saw that season and then saw him appearing to form a bond with Semhar and trying to protect her would be suspicious of keeping her.

[KELBEL]

Melissa Gorga's on Survivor, Semhar looks like MelGo

[Tilden]

, Tilden. Way to go, doggie!
People keep telling Semhar she's ok. I'm hoping they are lying...she won't be on the jury, why not lie and avoid the scene at camp, since she seems like a scene maker. And she's unlikely to be a Redemption Island threat to stay.

Yes, Doggie must have gotten the idea that being able to catch fish, even freeze-dried ones, is an admirable skill, but that you must think of your own needs first. Doggie needs to stop watching Survivor. He's now lying on the couch looking very pleased with himself--and burping.

[PWS]

Cochran only got a vote from Semhar...she's upset they lied. I agree, Tilden, get rid of the physically weak person who causes confrontations. Ozzy would really look odd supporting her. Not sure these folks saw the last season before they went to the South Pacific though...

Did anyone see the first 5 minutes? I missed them.

[Tilden]

Cochran only got a vote from Semhar...she's upset they lied. I agree, Tilden, get rid of the physically weak person who causes confrontations. Ozzy would really look odd supporting her. Not sure these folks saw the last season before they went to the South Pacific though...

Yeah, I wasn't sure about when the seasons were filmed either. On the other hand, it looks like it was a moot point--the only one who didn't vote for Semhar was Semhar herself. When push came to shove, Ozzie wasn't willing to risk going against the tribe to try and save her.