5/15 Show Discussion *spoilers*

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Tilden

If Natalie thought she could beat anyone, she was deluding herself. Ashely could have at least pointed out that she won immunity when she needed to, had she managed to make it to the final three.

And yeah, they might not have had the greatest shot against Andrea either, but if they'd managed to help oust Rob, they could point out that had they not gone along with Andrea, she would not have been able to oust him and that they had successfully used Rob until he became too much of a threat to keep him, at which point they strategically axed him. They would have looked far less stupid if they had done that, because it would have showed they'd been thinking at least a little bit.

If the three girls had managed to get rid of Phillip and Rob, they'd have had a better shot against each other. Yet none of them thought of that, except, perhaps, Andrea.

---

Yeah, if they would have at least taken a chance and somehow ousted Rob, the jury could have justified giving their vote to any of them but the way it went down there was just no way Rob could lose.

Well at least we won't be seeing Rob on Survivor since he got his money and title finally! Fourth time is the charm for him.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Passepartout

Well at least we won't be seeing Rob on Survivor since he got his money and title finally! Fourth time is the charm for him.

---

And even more important, he's got another show of his own to do!

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Passepartout

Well at least we won't be seeing Rob on Survivor since he got his money and title finally!

---

I'd really like to believe that but they will find some way to bring their beloved back somehow.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by rfromp

I'd really like to believe that but they will find some way to bring their beloved back somehow.

---

:barf

Goodness, surely not!

Just a question here. We viewers have had a variety of opinions about the addition of Redemption Island to "Survivor." What would be the reaction to this possible twist: Instead of having two RI survivors return to the group (at different times) where they risk getting voted out again, only one would return, and that person would automatically be one of the three finalists. In this past season, strategy around the camp would have been different if everyone was competing for one of two final slots instead of three, and there's a good chance that the RI returnee would have more friends on the jury than some of the other finalists. And when tribes were deciding who to send to RI, they would have to consider the possibility that they were selecting a finalist.