If There was a second installement of All-Stars...

[seanboy316]

Who would you like to see compete? Although the list should consist primarily of castaways from every season after the first All Stars, it can also include castaways from the first seven seasons, provided that they were not on "All Stars."

9 men, 9 women

Men:

Terry - Panama
Shane - Panama
Judd - Guatemala
Tom - Palau
Ian - Palau
Sarge - Vanauatu
Rory - Vanauatu
Chris - Vanauatu
John - Marquesas

Women:

Cirie - Panama
Sally - Panama
Danni - Guatemala
Stephenie - Guatemala
Angie - Palau
Ami - Vanauatu
Christa - Pearl Islands
Kelly G - Africa
Kelly W - Borneo

[OrangeDingo]

Men:

Terry - Panama (I'd like to see him go up against Tom)
Shane - Panama (Watching his insanity was awesomely entertaining)
Bob Dawg - Panama (I'd like to see him smash some fools)
Brian - Guatemala (I think he was a great player, but got nixed because of numbers)
Judd - Guatemala (Drama. Big, Hairy, Stinky Drama)
Coby - Palau (I'd like to watch him beat Tom, too)
Tom - Palau ( Terry vs. Tom )
Ian - Palau (Because I couldn't think of anybody else to put down)
Chad - Vanuatu (HE HAS ONE LEG.)


Women:

Misty - Panama (I think she was nixed too early. And she is like.. a Goddess)
Sally - Panama (Because she is Survivor Sal)
Cirie - Panama (Because she is Cirie)
Amy - Guatemala (She was a tough cookie)
Jolanda - Palau (Nixed way too early!)
Wanda - Palau (Because she never really got to play the game. So sad.)
Julie - Vanuatu (I think her whole 'Act-Like-Your-Sister' strategy was good)
Ami - Vanuatu (She was awesome)
Leann - Vanuatu (Leann had me laughing all the time.)

And there you have it. Not a whole bunch of power players, but I think it is a nice mix.

[Melsevene]

Who would you like to see compete? Although the list should consist primarily of castaways from every season after the first All Stars, it can also include castaways from the first seven seasons, provided that they were not on "All Stars."

9 men, 9 women

Men:

Terry - Panama
Shane - Panama
Judd - Guatemala
Tom - Palau
Ian - Palau
Sarge - Vanauatu
Rory - Vanauatu
Chris - Vanauatu
John - Marquesas

Women:

Cirie - Panama
Sally - Panama
Danni - Guatemala
Stephenie - Guatemala
Angie - Palau
Ami - Vanauatu
Christa - Pearl Islands
Kelly G - Africa
Kelly W - Borneo

I know so many of you don't like Aras, but he played a really amazingly smart game and it got him to the winner's circle. I think you'd have to include Aras, just cuz he's such a game player (kinda like Rob C., just not so obvious or grating to other players). But other than that, the only other person I'd really want included would be Amy from last season. That girl was so tough!

[rupertshoney]

Personally I'd love to see an AllStars with non winners only. I think it would be interesting to see what they've learned from the first time around, if they've changed their game plan and well to give more of them a chance because 9 out of 10 times they will vote off the winners anyway.Oh and also make sure people from the same season's weren't on the same tribe.

[Stump]

John - Marquesas

John from Marquesas? The guy who voted for Vecepia because Neleh didn't just let them vote her off? He was one of the lamest survivors ever, can't believe he's the one you choose from that season.

What about for the men: Hunter, Sean, Paschal (blue rock guy), or even Rob?

[Jelani]

What about for the men: Hunter, Sean, Paschal (blue rock guy), or even Rob?

I agree about Hunter...he was robbed by the LAZY duo of Rob and Sean..well..and Vee too..

And..the rock was purple..not blue..hehe..EVIL Purple rock...but I think that was divine intervention considering he collapsed a couple days later..

[DeafChulo]

How about Christy (Deaf survivor competitor)? I'm sure she'll learn this time around to trust NO one and just "go along" with the voting then change vote behind the backs rather than announced it at tribal meeting. (which resulted in her being voted out) :-P

[seanboy316]

John from Marquesas? The guy who voted for Vecepia because Neleh didn't just let them vote her off? He was one of the lamest survivors ever, can't believe he's the one you choose from that season.

What about for the men: Hunter, Sean, Paschal (blue rock guy), or even Rob?

All deserving candidates as well. Well maybe not the General. I never liked him.

As far as John, I believe that he controlled the first half of the game very well. John's mistake (along with the rest of his alliance) was showing his hand during the rope choping immunity challenge. I would wager to say that John played as well as Robfather that season, IMHO. I would have no problem putting him in an edition of All Stars.

[Fossil]

I would like to see a game filled with people who NEVER lifted a finger around camp their first time around. Then we watch them all starve the second time.

[Newfherder]

If there was another All-Star season of Survivor, it would free up my Thursday evenings. After the last lame attempt, I will not watch All-Star anything. I will not be watching Big Brother this summer because for that reason (that and the fear that Ivette the Chupacabra will return--what a hideous woman!)