A new thought on the big lie - **spoilers**

[Jupiter]

I'm kind of suspicious of Lil..and I'm leaning toward "she" may be a "he". Oh well..we'll find out Wednesday..but its fun guessing!

[getreal]

I'm kind of suspicious of Lil..and I'm leaning toward "she" may be a "he". Oh well..we'll find out Wednesday..but its fun guessing!

I dunno ... did you see her thighs during the keelhauling challenge when B&L first returned?
Maybe Rupert returns after the judges decide that Burton didn't win the immunity challenge fairly.

[Bill]

Burton won the challenge more than fair. Not sure what the problem was. Yes, he was at the bottom, but he shared the bottom spot with someone else, I will have to go back and look. Sandra took him out on purpose I believe.

[Joe_Madre]

It seems to obviosu that the liar is Jon....but I wouldnt be surprised to hear him lie about anything.
Even though most people hate him he is doing what it takes to win this game.....I hope he keeps it up.

[Jupiter]

Did I miss something in the IC....what happened that Burton may not have won it fairly?

[pink_princess]

Did I miss something in the IC....what happened that Burton may not have won it fairly?

I think the feeling is that given the natural downward trajectory of darts, being the pie-wedge on the bottom of the wheel makes you more likely to be hit that if you were at the top. Jiffy apparently was being feeble while he spun the wheel (or else it was unfairly weighted) because Rupert and Burton both had their wedge end up at the bottom more often than anyone else, making them more likely to be hit than anyone else.

Burton was damn good at the game though, I don't think there was any question that he didn't win on his own merit. It's a bummer that Sandra "accidentally" hit Rupert, but I'm sure even if she hadn't, Burton would have been gunning for him anyway and he'd have been out just as soon.

I can't even fathom anything having happened in last week's show that could result in Rupert coming back, as much as I'd like to see him in the game. Whatever funny business goes on with the IC happens on tomorrow's show and given the usual editing job, is probably way less dramatic than the commercials make it out to be.

Sort of like someone finishes a race neck and neck with someone and the wrong person is declared the winner, so they run the race again. I doubt it's related to the big lie, but then again, I was wrong about what that was too.

[Shakenbake]

Maybe the big lie is Burton saying he was a boy scout. Not that big of a lie, but it got Lil's trust.

[Scoobs]

There is no way in the world that Rupert is coming back, otherwise they would be promoting the hell out of it.

"A castaway's unfair chances results in somebody coming back into the tribe. Stay tuned on the next dramatic episode of Survivor on it's special night"

[Wayner]

Well, based on the local vegetation, I think it'll wind up being either lemon chifon or coconut creme.

Wait... this isn't the Big Pie thread, is it? Um, nevermind.

[Joe_Madre]

Well, based on the local vegetation, I think it'll wind up being either lemon chifon or coconut creme.

Wait... this isn't the Big Pie thread, is it? Um, nevermind.

LOL