Every catcher can be a back up catcher, true, but not every catcher can be a knuckleball catcher and therein lies Mirabellis fundamental value. Knuckleballers historically have their own catchers- their effectiveness is tied directly to their catchers. How important is Mirabelli to The Red Sox ? So important the Yankees tried to trade for him this week so as to neautralize Wakefields effectiveness .My feeling is The Red Sox lucked out in getting Mirabelli back as S.D initially obtained Mirabelli so he could be their everyday catcher, - relegating him to back up once they signed Mike Piazza.
" I'm a Republican. I only seem liberal because I believe hurricanes are caused by high barometric pressure, not gay marriage."- Will Macavoy The Newsroom
Very true, but I don't think the Sox thought Bard would be that bad. They figured he'd improve after a few weeks, just like Mirabelli when he first got here, but that never happened and they can't afford to wait it out.