4/17 Show Discussion Thread **SPOILERS**

[withoutasol]

I think that it was real sweet how Melissa R stuck up for Chelsea and told her not to listen to those bitches.

Melissa S is a bitch! Chelsea might have had it easier by being on the swing, but Melissa S wasn't all that grand in that tub either.

[Jewelsy]

I'm basing my dislike of Melissa S on watching about 25 minutes of one show this entire season, so it is good to know I'm not entirely off the mark in my assessment.
I actually shouted "HA!" when she was booted

Me too! Fluffster, she's been pulling that anti-Chelsea crap for the last two weeks. I think she lost a lot of fans after that last week. Stupid, stupid girl. :nono

[rt1ky]

I was so sick of Melissa S. She's now been rejected by 2 reality tv show music competitions.

I agree with others that the jealousy and hate for Chelsea was childish and bratty. At least Chelsea lasted longer than her rival.

[Bearcata]

Glad Melissa S is gone, gone, gone. The smirking was a bit too much.

[Foamylives]

Can I say that for all the 'talent' Asia has, she REALLY isn't the brightest crayon in the box? The PCD may not be known for intelligence because of their music, but all the ones we've seen so far on the show have been articulate, interesting, smart women.

Asia on the other hand? She's had more cringeworthy moments of idiocy that could rival even JESSICA SIMPSON.

Why would they want HER?

[Foamylives]

what was the other show Melissa S was on? Was she an american idol alum?

[miadora]

Thank god I can die a happy woman.

Melissa should've thanked Chelsea for her bangs; even though they don't hide her crookedly-jacked nose, they help.

[LS0919]

Melissa S. was on MTV's Making the Band 3. The girls who won that show are now in the band, Danity Kane.

[Misaru]

I think it's between Melissa and Chelsea now. I never liked Asia and I don't know what people see in her, other than the finger twitching and the lips that never close.

I was rooting for Melissa R from early on and I really think she has IT. When she sings, she really makes it her own and commands the attention. I kinda don't want her to win though, just because I want to see her solo.

I hope Chelsea would win because I think she is the best singer and she blends very well with the rest of the PCD. Height-wise, I think Chelsea is just right and Melissa is a bit too short. Dancing-wise, she may never be the best dancer ever, but she can learn to be a pretty darn good one.

Boy, am I glad Melissa S is gone. Does anyone know which reality show she's vying for next?

[DixiePixie]

I missed the show again, but VERY excited to see the bitch.. (oops) go!

I don't know what is up with tv programming in my area b/c it never airs when the rest of the world does LOL