Asia

[kimanis]

Oops! I said Indian when referring to Asia when I should have written Native....sorry, no offense meant by that.

[Google]

 

[KELBEL]

Why is Ron Fair so unfair?

[kimrs]

Originally Posted by KELBEL

Why is Ron Fair so unfair?

What do you mean? In what ways do you see him as being unfair?

[GossipGirlANTM]

Originally Posted by kimrs

What do you mean? In what ways do you see him as being unfair?

He hates Asia!
It's pretty obvious.
Oh well....I couldn't care less since I don't like her either.....

[KELBEL]

Originally Posted by kimrs

What do you mean? In what ways do you see him as being unfair?

Because he doesnt like her, how can you be a judge without being fair, I think last episode was her best.

[ChicagoViewer]

Originally Posted by KELBEL

Because he doesnt like her, how can you be a judge without being fair, I think last episode was her best.

I think he's being completely fair--his comments are always dead on. She WAS off on the vocal and she DOES have that annoying finger-tapping-on-the-mic habit. And he's being just as critical of the other girls. It's not like he's gushing love for anyone.

[KELBEL]

Originally Posted by ChicagoViewer

I think he's being completely fair--his comments are always dead on. She WAS off on the vocal and she DOES have that annoying finger-tapping-on-the-mic habit. And he's being just as critical of the other girls. It's not like he's gushing love for anyone.

I stand by my view hes doesnt like her and is extra critical of her, everytime she performs the cameras go on Ron Fair and his face says it all. Like I said before in my opinion her last performance were was good, he said she is good singer but....

[SuperBrat]

Originally Posted by ChicagoViewer

I think he's being completely fair--his comments are always dead on. She WAS off on the vocal and she DOES have that annoying finger-tapping-on-the-mic habit. And he's being just as critical of the other girls. It's not like he's gushing love for anyone.

oh man, I am SO glad I am not the only one who noticed that! She may be the most overrated one on this whole show. Her voice anoys me, she is not all that cute in my opinion, and seriously, why the finger waves when she sings? Does she think it will somehow make her more diva-liscious? All it did was have me burst out laughing on the couch whenever she sings. It was a good distraction from the weirdness of her voice.

[ChicagoViewer]

Originally Posted by KELBEL

I stand by my view hes doesnt like her and is extra critical of her, everytime she performs the cameras go on Ron Fair and his face says it all. Like I said before in my opinion her last performance were was good, he said she is good singer but....

You're welcome to think he's picking on her, just like I'm welcome to point out he's not. Cameras go to him when she's singing to show he's displeased with her singing--and I think rightfully so. She's the weakest singer remaining--Chelsea, Melissa R and Melissa S would all kick her butt in a sing-off. Ron is, after all, a record producer, so he's more concerned with the quality of their voices than he is with their dance moves.

[KELBEL]

I dont think she is a terrible singer her style of singing is different as was Sisely (who was more "rocker"). Asia's style is more "r&b" or "diva" as is her dancing.