WHile Mondo's was VERY junior and commercial, I would have put Gretchen there instead but had her be safe. The only thing that saved Ivy (besides the show needing a bad guy since Gretchen seems to be the controlling, belittling manner edit) was that at least hers flowed. It was bland and boring, but it flowed. C's was actually nice looking for a luncheon at a resort catering to older cliental. Not all resorts are tropical and beachy, but even I knew what they wanted. They wanted tropical resort wear.
I personally have never been to a resort of any type. I didn't get the nightgown win, although the top was cute and I've seen stuff like that on an MTV red carpet. The dress was OK, but I don't see how it is beach resort wear. By default, Andy's seem to be the winner. I wasn't moved by any of them.
I'm rambling, so I'm going to stop.