I really thought Josh was going to win based on what the judges said. Also a couple of seasons back when Ule, I think her name was, the German lady who lived in Miami, was not voted as the season winner because she designed resort wear just like Anya does. I was very surprised Victor Luna did not win based on his work. The judges criteria seems to be so inconsistent on who should win and who should stay it drives me batty. They did the exact same thing on episode 1 of Project Runway, kept the one designer over the other because of her potential not what was created for the challenge.