I totally agree with your opinions. I thought the winner should have been Andy South. That was a very cool outfit - both the suit and the cover-up. I didn't like April's at all. It looked more like something you would wear to turn on a lover in the bedroom, not at poolside (or Red Carpet - what!!). Ivy should have gone home. I actually liked Casanova's top and pants. I'd wear them and I don't think they look at all like something a grandma would wear. The judging leaves me shaking my head at times. Ivy's design was very plain and like something you could whip up from a pattern you could find in Butterick or Simplicity.