9/22 Show Discussion **West Coast Spoilers**

[Bearcata]

What guy wears white jeans? Oh, yeah a house painter, but they are probably overalls. Get real this challenge was a bust the only pants that even looked like they fit in the crotch were Bert's, Joshua's and Victor's.

[princessKIM]

I'm not going to miss Oliver...What a drip!

[ryansmommy]

Just out of sheer curiosity I would like to know how Olivier grew up-he is so out of touch with reality. I had to laugh when the band started playing and he covered his ears in shock, like that was the first time he had heard any sound above a breathy whisper. Not only was it a bit rude (the band probably thought he didn't like their music), but it was just overly dramatic. And don't get me started on his definition of 'plus size'! He truly seemed offended that he would be asked to design anything for anyone bigger than a 6 foot tall stick. Sadly I really wanted to like him, but the antics of the past few weeks have totally turned me off. I am actually starting to like Josh a bit more- which in and of itself is kind-of scary!

That is an easy one ... sadly, Olivier grew up spoiled.

[Jexter]

The promise of Olivier has finally imploded for it has became evident that Olivier is only successful when working with a dress form that accurately mimics the challenge's model.

Anyway, now we know why he bitterly complained about large breasts and, during this particular challenge, insisted the band's lead singer as plus-size.

.

Well, as much as I'm NOT an Oliver fan, I have to agree that his collection was pretty nice. My favs:

Anya
Bert
Viktor
Oliver

I predict - and would like to see - a Victor victory, but I generally have no clue about this stuff. I could see F2 being Joshua and Anya. It would be pretty fun to watch Joshua go up against Bert for the win...their stuff is apples and oranges.

[Dragonlady]

I think ALL the designs were awful and ridiculous. None looked like a rock band members' clothes. Too feminine, more like charactures of a rocker. Everyone missed the mark although there were a few good ideas here and there.
Most would look great on the Brady Bunch family or a high school production of a '60's rock group with costumes made by the moms.
Glad Olivier is gone. I still think he should not have won for the pet shop contest, winning with a design that another was admonished for.

[Duckyface]

Finally, I thought, we have a great challenge allowing for out of the box creativity, but alas they all failed miserably. They all looked like something the wardrobe department of a t.v. movie of the week's version of a 70's rock band. I was hoping for so much more. I know they are used to designing for men and was ready to make allowances for that, but I didn't even see anything original attempted

[Arielflies]

Well, this is a jeans wearing band, so the tops would make the image. The irony is the preview where they will be designing more fashion from the 70's - or hopefully, re-designing.

[jadewarlock]

Looking at that final press print of Victor's winning design, I have to say though that they did design the band rather well around that outfit. They did manage to make the design cohesive and the like. I do think however the daisy shirt was removed in favor of a plaid shirt or some other design, which admittedly works better.

Probably Victor's truly was the best of the outfits to fit the band's style and music (and it does have that '70s vibe to it), and then Bert's was second. The others didn't work right.

[NCLurker]

This week just made me more curious about Oliver. It just seems that there are so many oddities that are present in Asperger's Syndrome. It makes me wonder.