How would you rank the guests (past & present?)

Thank you irn for stating my own opinion almost to a T, except for perhaps the part about Zack. As far as his looks I never thought him anything other than average in looks (personality aside), from day one I never saw the hot part (although his personality is why I grew to not like him). In the looks dept I put him and Amy, and Dave in the same catagory as being average and plain in apperance. There is also something about Holly's face that is strange to me. I can't quite put my finger on it (maybe it is her expressions, I don't know). Sometimes I look at her and see her as being very beautiful, and other times I look at her and see her as quite plain. Does anyone else experience that in regards to her?

The person that rated Charla as being a 1 for trustworthy and then rated Tom as an 8 , I don't understand that. Tom told Dave he had his and Keith's backs and then went and laughed about it and said how much he hated Dave. That doesn't sound trustworthy to me. (Note: if it had been anybody doing it to anyone else, I would still think them untrustworthy, it is not a Originals vs Barbies issue to me).

Tara
Looks- 7
Mental Stabiblity- 5
Personality- 2
Honest-Trustworthy- 1
Total- 15/40
Comments: Nobody trust this bitch. She may be pretty but she'll seduce you then stab you in the back!


Dave
Looks- 2
Mental Stabiblity- 6
Personality- 3
Honest-Trustworthy- 2
Total- 13/40
Comments: Poor guy...he knew that he'd never get any action so all of his time at the hotel was used scheming and plotting.


Keith
Looks- 3
Mental Stability- 5
Personality- 1
Honest-Trustworthy- 1
Total- 10/40
Comments: Ew, no comment.


Charla
Looks- 5
Mental Stability- 1
Personality- 1
Honest-Trustworthy- 1
Total- 8/40
Comments: Why would you even go on a reality show dedicated to partying and hooking up if you're that anti-social?


Holly
Looks- 9
Mental Stability- 8
Personality- 8
Honest-Trustworthy- 8
Total- 33/40
Comments: Gotta love Holly! :D


Kristin
Looks- 9
Mental Stability- 9
Personality- 7
Honest-Trustworthy- 5
Total- 30/40
Comments: Just there to have a good time and whats wrong with that?!


Scott
Looks- 8
Mental Stabiblity- 10
Personality- 10
Honest-Trustworthy- 10
Total- 38/40
Comments: Scott is the smartest and most trustworthy guy in the game. He deserves to win.


Kavita
Looks- 2
Mental Stabiblity- 7
Personality- 2
Honest-Trustworthy- 4
Total- 15/40
Comments: Why did they even allow this nasty chick a chance to come on the show?


Matthew
Looks- 2
Mental Stabiblity- 6
Personality- 3
Honest-Trustworthy- 5
Total- 16/40
Comments: ---

Melanie
Looks- 7
Mental Stability- 9
Personality- 8
Honest-Trustworthy- 10
Total- 34/40
Comments: It was really nice of her not to really try and come between Holly and Scott when she came back..


Andon
Looks- 7
Mental Stability- 10
Personality- 9
Honest-Trustworthy- 8
Total- 34/40
Comments: Cool guy and really should have stayed instead of Dave!


Tom
Looks- 9
Mental Stability- 9
Personality- 9
Honest-Trustworthy- 10
Total- 37/40
Comments: One of the best guys in the show and it's a shame he was kicked off last week!


Alex
Looks- 10
Mental Stability- 9
Personality- 8
Honest-Trustworthy- 5
Total- 32/40
Comments: Hottest guy on the show....wasn't very trustworthy though.


Beau
Looks- 10
Mental Stability- 10
Personality- 10
Honest-Trustworthy- 10
Total- 40/40
Comments:Straightforward, honest and hot...what more could a girl ask for?!


Amanda
Looks- 8
Mental Stability- 6
Personality- 6
Honest-Trustworthy- 6
Total- 26/40
Comments: I liked her at first..then she became a bit of a basketcase.


Zack
Looks- 9
Mental Stability- 9
Personality- 8
Honest-Trustworthy- 8
Total- 34/40
Comments: :heart He really made the show what it is..


Amy
Looks- 6
Mental Stability- 6
Personality- 8
Honest-Trustworthy- 8
Total- 28/40
Comments: Really misjudged by some...


Toni
Looks- 7
Mental Stability- 6
Personality- 6
Honest-Trustworthy- 8
Total- 27/40
Comments: She had the best quotes in the show! "Excuse me?! EXCUSE ME!!" haha

I'll take a stab at a few of them -

Amy
Looks - 5 (Normal)
Mental - 2
Personality - 1 (Somewhere around a cockroach) :cuss
Honest - 10 (I definitely know her position on things!)
= 19

Zach
Looks - 6
Mental - 1 (Egads) :barf
Personality - 1 (The Monkey gestures were the last straw)
Honest - 5
= 14

Keith
Looks - 5 (I don't get why people find him attractive) :confused
Mental - 9
Personality - 9
Honest - 7 (As honest as you can be and still play the game)
= 30

Dave
Looks - 2
Mental - 7
Personality - 7 (Sometimes handles himself very well/ sometimes not.)
Honest - 8
= 24

Charla
Looks - 9
Mental - 6 (the pity parties have got to stop) :violin
Personality - 5
Honest - 9 (I don't think she's leading Dave on - He's leading himself on)
= 29

Scott
Looks - 10 (Definitely the babe of the men) :biglove
Mental - 9
Personality - 5 (Who knows? He morphs depending on the circumstance)
Honest - 3 (Sneaky, sneaky, sneaky)
= 27

Tara
Looks - 9
Mental -8
Personality - 7
Honest - 7
= 30

Toni :omg
Looks - 7 (She can be gorgeous or gorilla-like, depends)
Mental - 3 (GAME ON!)
Personality - 7 (enjoyable for the sheer entertainment value)
Honest - 7
= 24

I couldn't care less about Holly (needy), Melanie (ok), Kristin (mean), Desiree (follower), Tom (what the...?), Andon (a**hole), Alex (a**hole also), Matt (nice), Kavita (super nice), etc.

1. Tara
9- Mental Stability
9- Looks
9- Personality
9- Honest- Trustworthy
36/40 Total

2. Scott
9- Mental Stability
6- Looks
8- Personality
8- Honest- Trustworthy
31/40 Total

3. Keith
8- Mental Stability
6- Looks
7- Personality
9- Honest- Trustworthy
30/40 Total

4. Tom
7- Mental Stability
8- Looks
6- Personality
8- Honest- Trustworthy
29/40 Total

5. Amanda
7- Mental Stability
7- Looks
7- Personality
7- Honest- Trustworthy
28/40 Total

6. Holly
7- Mental Stability
9- Looks
5- Personality
6- Honest- Trustworthy
27/40 Total

7. Charla
6- Mental Stability
8- Looks
6- Personality
6- Honest- Trustworthy
26/40 Total

8. Kavita
7- Mental Stability
6- Looks
5- Personality
8- Honest- Trustworthy
26/40 Total

9. Alex
8- Mental Stability
9- Looks
6- Personality
3- Honest- Trustworthy
26/40 Total

10. Beau
7- Mental Stability
8- Looks
6- Personality
5- Honest- Trustworthy
26/40 Total

11. Matthew
7- Mental Stability
4- Looks
7- Personality
6- Honest- Trustworthy
24/40 Total

12. Kristin
7- Mental Stability
9- Looks
5- Personality
3- Honest- Trustworthy
24/40 Total

13. Dave
7- Mental Stability
4- Looks
7- Personality
5- Honest- Trustworthy
23/40 Total

14. Melanie
7- Mental Stability
6- Looks
4- Personality
5- Honest- Trustworthy
22/40 Total

15. Amy
4- Mental Stability
6- Looks
5- Personality
6- Honest- Trustworthy
21/40 Total

16. Andon
6- Mental Stability
3- Looks
3- Personality
2- Honest- Trustworthy
14/40 Total

17. Toni
5- Mental Stability
3- Looks
1- Personality
3- Honest- Trustworthy
12/40 Total

18. Zack
5- Mental Stability
3- Looks
1- Personality
2- Honest- Trustworthy
11/40 Total

how could i forget...my comments

tara..very pretty, most normal/down to earth

scott..one of the more mature guests; seems to have a nice personality

keith..very bold, not so concerned what everyone else thinks... just looks after himself and his alliance (until dave screwed up!!)

tom..i was sad to see him go; he started to grow on me in the end

amanda..annoying first part of show; i really liked her when she came back

holly..her voice annoys the hell out of me; very needy and enjoys arguing with scott- always picking a fight and whining about something; very pretty

charla..good ole charla- pretty, a little underestimated as to her sneakiness; smarter than she may come off- otherwise she would not have made it this far

kavita..nothing much to say- blah

alex..very good looking, but a snake!

beau..good looking but a whiner; never happy always complaining; wants to seem smarter than he is

matthew...same as kavita; wants to be a womanizer, but just does not have it

kristin..very pretty, but can not think for herself; always follows the crowd

dave..poor dave- i guess he made it this far, but man- he is annoying; he is scheming and dirty, but he gets it done

melanie..annoying and not very cute

amy..uuggghhhh! poor girl lost all of her friends; if i were at paradise i would not get close to her because everyone she was close to got kicked off; a little nuts and "in love" with a complete idiot

andon..a little bit of a moron; quite obnoxious

toni..where in the hell does she get that "america loves her"???? she is a monster with extremely low self-esteem and a big bully as a result; i pity the man she bullies into marrying her

zack..one of the most unintelligent people ever placed on reality television (right up there with evan marriott (aka joe millionaire)); not even attractive, nice body but that's it, and he should definitely talk less- he would come off much smarter if he simply never spoke....became a mute maybe!


Desiree..left her off, but not much to say; at the end she just said mean things to get on television; she was trying to be part of the "in crowd" but was not very good at it; she should have stuck with charla and tara!
7- Mental Stability
5- Looks
1- Personality
2- Honest- Trustworthy
15/40 Total

Tara :flirt

looks-9
mental stability-8
personality-8
honest-trustworthy-9
total-34

Keith :D
looks-8
mental stability-9
personality-9
honest-trustworthy-8
total-34

Dave :whip

looks-4
mental stability-7
personality-8
honest-trustworthy-7
total-26

Charla :bowdown

looks-10
mental stability-8
personality-9
honest-trustworthy-9
total-36

Holly :rolleyes

looks-8
mental stability-8
personality-5
honest-trustworthy-8
total-30

Kristin :eek

looks-9
mental stability-7
personality-7
honest-trustworthy-8
total-31

Scott :props

looks-8
mental stability-8
personality-9
honest-trustworthy-9
total-34

Kavita :winkgrin

looks-7
mental stability-8
personality-7
honest-trustworthy-8
total-30

Matthew :guitar

looks-7
mental stability-8
personality-9
honest-trustworthy-8
total-32

Melanie :ohno

looks-7
mental stability-7
personality-8
honest-trustworthy-7
total-29

Andon :guzzle

looks-8
mental stability-7
personality-9
honest-trustworthy-5
total-29

Tom :monkeybum

looks-7
mental stability-6
personality-7
honest-trustworthy-3
total-23

Alex :lovestruc

looks-10
mental stability-8
personality-7
honest-trustworthy-5
total-30

Beau :cuss

looks-7
mental stability-7
personality-5
honest-trustworthy-6
total-25

Amanda :cool:

looks-7
mental stability-8
personality-9
honest-trustworthy-8
total-34

Zack :pissedoff

looks-9
mental stability-6
personality-2
honest-trustworthy-4
total-21

Amy :stupid

looks-4
mental stability-4
personality-5
honest-trustworthy-6
total-19

Toni :barf

looks-3
mental stability-5
personality-6
honest-trustworthy-4
total-18

Rank each guest in the following 4 Categories

Looks 10 being best
Mental Stability 10 being best
Personality 10 being best
Honest - Trustworthy 10 being best
Total Score 40 possible

Comments: say what you feel!

Guests:

Tara
looks: 9
mental stability: 9
personality: 8
honest:8
total:34
comments: tara was definitely one of the best...she was there for charla and was a true friend. she is a little flaunting of herself at times, but if i was that hot, i would be too.

Dave
looks: 6
mental stability:7
personality:6
honest:3
total:22
comments:i do like dave, but he became such a liar at the end of the show. i think he just is trying to be sneaky and isn't good at it. i feel bad for the guy with the whole charla thing. he definitely added some humor to the show with his man boobs

Keith
looks: 9
mental stability: 9
personality:8
honest:9
total:35
comments:my boyfriend knew keith in high school and he was a cool guy. i also think he was the most honest and down to earth person on the show. he was my favorite.

Charla
looks: 8
mental stability: 6
personality:7
honest:9
total:30
comments:bless her heart, she made it. she was so unsure of herself you just want to scream at her that she's hot and sweet. don't let the silicone clique get you down.

Holly
looks: 6
mental stability:5
personality:2
honest:6
total:19
comments:she's dumb. enough said.

Kristin
looks: 6
mental stability:8
personality:4
honest:4
total:22
comments:did anyone else notice how kristin's boobs just got bigger and bigger as her brain got smaller and smaller?

Scott
looks: 7
mental stability:8
personality:5
honest:6
total:26
comments:scott really annoyed me at the end with all his pressure on keith. you picked holly as your partner, and that's why you don't deserve to win

Kavita
looks: 9
mental stability:8
personality:8
honest:8
total:33
comments:i liked her, i wish she would have gotten to stay on longer.

Matthew
looks: 6
mental stability:7
personality:4
honest:3
total:20
comments:cocky and annoying, also backstabbing to charla. dont like him.

Melanie
looks: 6
mental stability:6
personality:6
honest:6
total:24
comments:hey you got kicked off twice because no one cares

Andon
looks: 5
mental stability:5
personality:4
honest:3
total:17
comments:nice tattoo toni lover

Tom
looks: 7
mental stability:4
personality:4
honest:4
total:19
comments:he has a pet stuffed monkey...does that worry anyone else?

Alex
looks: 8
mental stability:6
personality:3
honest:3
total:20
comments:if he wasn't attractive he would be even more worthless

Beau
looks: 7
mental stability:5
personality:4
honest:3
total:19
comments:in his own words "the annoying one is back"!

Amanda
looks: 7
mental stability:6
personality:7
honest:8
total:28
comments:at least she gave beau a chance...he needed someone to calm him down.

Zack
looks: 6
mental stability:5
personality:3
honest:4
total:18
comments:wow zack, you are so obnoxious

Amy
looks: 5
mental stability:5
personality:3
honest:2
total:15
comments:bitch

Toni
looks: 4
mental stability:3
personality:6
honest:3
total:16
comments:she just scares me. if her eyes pop out one more time...

Tara
Looks-6
Mental Stabiblity-6
Personality-2 (doesn’t know how to stand up for herself. Whenever someone talks crap to her all she does is say “okay..okay (I’m an idiot) okay”)
Honest-Trustworthy-5
Total-19/40

Dave
Looks-4
Mental Stabiblity-7
Personality-6
Honest-Trustworthy-2
Total-19/40

Keith
Looks-5
Mental Stabiblity-7
Personality-6
Honest-Trustworthy-5
Total-23/40

Charla
Looks-8 (shed get more if she wasn’t so skinny)
Mental Stabiblity-7 (she acts normal)
Personality-7
Honest-Trustworthy-2
Total-24/40

Holly
Looks-2 (she looks like shes been terribly burnt)
Mental Stabiblity-4
Personality-1 (she never talks, and when she does she sounds so annoying)
Honest-Trustworthy-8
Total-15/40

Kristin
Looks-5 (shed get more if it were not for the implants)
Mental Stabiblity-6
Personality-4 (we don’t see much of her)
Honest-Trustworthy-2
Total-17/40

Scott
Looks-7
Mental Stabiblity-10
Personality-6
Honest-Trustworthy-8
Total-31/40

Tom
Looks-7
Mental Stabiblity-9
Personality-8 ( I didnt like what he said when he was trying to get in, but on the show he seemed pretty decent)
Honest-Trustworthy-7
Total-31/40

Alex
Looks-8
Mental Stabiblity-7
Personality-4
Honest-Trustworthy-2
Total-21/40

Beau
Looks-5
Mental Stabiblity-4
Personality-2 (hes so annoying)
Honest-Trustworthy-6
Total-17/40

Amanda
Looks-3 (so plain looking)
Mental Stabiblity-5
Personality-5
Honest-Trustworthy-6
Total-19/40

Zack
Looks-8
Mental Stabiblity-2
Personality-1 (he acts so immature)
Honest-Trustworthy-5
Total-16/40

Amy
Looks-7 (shes pretty)
Mental Stabiblity-6 (am I the only one who thinks it’s a good thing to stand up for yourself?)
Personality-6
Honest-Trustworthy-8
Total-21/40

Toni
Looks-5 (shed be prettier if she wasn’t so manly)
Mental Stabiblity-7
Personality-8
Honest-Trustworthy-8
Total-28/40

Amy-
Looks- 4.0
Mental Stability- 2.1
Personality- 3.2
Honest Trustworthy 5.8
Total- 15.1/40

Zack-
Looks- 1.1
Mental Stability- 2.6
Personality- 3.6 (EGO)
Honest Trustworthy- 1.3
Total- 8.6/40

Toni-
Looks- 0.0
Mental Stability- 2.2
Personality- 1.9
Honest- 4.2
Total- 8.3/40

Beau
Looks- 5.4
Mental Stability- 3.8
Personality- 6.2
Honest- 2.4
Total- 17.8/40

Dave
Looks- 0.0
Mental Stability- 7.2
Personality- 3.6
Honest- 8.7
Total- 19.5/40

Charla-
Looks- 10.0
Mental Stability- 9.8
Personality- 8.8
Honest- 10.0
Total- 38.6/40

Tara-
Looks- 7.2
Mental Stability- 6.2
Personality- 4.8
Honest- 3.9
Total- 22.1/40

Scott-
Looks- 2.1
Mental Stability- 7.6
Personality- 8.8
Honest- 9.0
Total- 27.5/40

I Dont wanna do the rest!

Tara:
Looks- 7
Mental Stability- 8
Personality- 5
Honest Trustworthy - 2

Dave:
Looks- 4
Mental Stability- 8
Personality- 8
Honest Trustworthy - 5

Keith:
Looks- 6
Mental Stability- 7
Personality- 9
Honest Trustworthy - 9

Charla:
Looks- 10
Mental Stability- 4
Personality- 8
Honest Trustworthy - 10

Holly:
Looks- 8
Mental Stability- 8
Personality- 4
Honest Trustworthy - 8

Kristin:
Looks- 5
Mental Stability- 7
Personality- 3
Honest Trustworthy - 1

Scott:
Looks- 6
Mental Stability- 10
Personality- 9
Honest Trustworthy - 10

Kavita:
Looks- 7
Mental Stability- 8
Personality- 8
Honest Trustworthy - 8

Matthew:
Looks- 10
Mental Stability- 7
Personality- 7
Honest Trustworthy - 8

Melanie:
Looks- 3
Mental Stability- 5
Personality- 2
Honest Trustworthy - 5

Andon:
Looks- 2
Mental Stability- 5
Personality- 1
Honest Trustworthy - 1

Tom:
Looks- 8
Mental Stability- 7
Personality- 9
Honest Trustworthy - 6

Alex:
Looks- 6
Mental Stability- 4
Personality- 5
Honest Trustworthy - 1

Beau:
Looks- 7
Mental Stability- 5
Personality- 9
Honest Trustworthy - 7

Amanda:
Looks- 8
Mental Stability- 4
Personality- 7
Honest Trustworthy - 6

Zack:
Looks- 3
Mental Stability- 5
Personality- 1
Honest Trustworthy - 2

Amy:
Looks- 5
Mental Stability- 1
Personality- 3
Honest Trustworthy - 7

Toni:
Looks- 1
Mental Stability- 4
Personality- 1
Honest Trustworthy - 1