Well, I had admittedly wondered if they would do this show again because the second season did have one of the two contestants figure it out that the show was fake.
Still - waiting at least two years has apparently helped out because they've brought it back, and it looks like they got their mark quite well on who is being duped.
Joe Schmo returns tomorrow (Jan. 8) at 10 p.m./9 CST on Spike.
Me? - I think it'll be interesting and fun to see if the guy knows and plays along, calls them out on it or is genuinely duped.