I agree that this is way fake. But a couple of thoughts. Not every Amish person has a German accent. In my business I deal with a lot of them, and like other people who learn a second language, some people have accents, and some people don't. So that's not really an indicator. But Sabrina has pierced ears! That would not be tolerated as they don't wear jewelry, not even wedding rings. And the boys surely did not have Amish haircuts at the start. Of course they could pull the "Rumspringa" card and say they were trying things on the outside when they were picked for the show. And the pole dancing! I can't fathom she'd never seen it done before. And there's a difference between someone whose morals are solid, but just doesn't want to live under those rules, and someone who wants to do things like wear provocative clothing and act sleazy. I'll still watch though. It's like waiting for an accident to happen, can't keep your eyes off it.