I got involved in this particular discussion so indulge me and allow me to say a few further words. Woofgang's assertion that Kate didn't know the pinata would be empty could be right. All the pinatas looked the same and were already hung when the Gosselins got to the party. In that case, there was an oversight and one of the pinatas wasn't filled and I retract my earlier assessment of the situation.Originally Posted by mushybrain;3927050;
I'm neither fan nor foe of Kate but I'll say this: there's an awful lot of speculation about her motives and judgment of her actions, and an awful lot of it comes from commenters who aren't watching her but are commenting about how she is portrayed or commenting about what they hear about her. I think that's unfair, the same way it wouldn't be fair to review a movie before seeing it or a book before reading it.
I think anyone who wants to discuss Kate (or any other show or personality) owes it to themselves and the subject to watch the show before commenting.