Also, I think the judges neglected to give credit for Milk's performance in the musical. They played up the Battle of the Idols gimmick so much that I think everyone ele got ignored. Milk's performance at the end was really touching. Sure he isn't really a singer, but he was disciplined and you could tell he learned from whatever the director told him. He didn't always hit the right notes, but he showed some real technique, and he added just the right amount of heart to cap the show after all that camp and snark.