Originally Posted by Krom;3057310;
No, they were broader cliches, not specifically "reality show judge cliches" (although yes, there were two guys and one woman).
First we had the gay guy. A super-over-the-top one, who not only had the mannerisms and the lisp, but also (on air) made lascivious comments about wanting to have sex with all of the male celebrities, while referring to the ladies as "home girls" and stuff like that.
Second, we had a circus specific cliche--the female French trapeze artist, desperately trying to hold onto her youth with tons of cosmetics, calling everyone "darleeng" and "cherie", and (I'm just betting) chain-smoking during every break.
Third, we had some gymnast guy, who actually didn't seem to fit that well, but well... seemed like every other gymnast guy who's taken some kind of talking-head role after his retirement.
In terms of the scoring though, the French lady was kind of the Simon. Or maybe if we base this on DWTS, the Len Goodman. Usually she was a point lower in scoring than the other two. The gay guy kind of scored like Bruno, from DWTS. He'd get really enthusiastic about someone and score high, but it seems like he can also turn on a dime and toss out a really low score just because he's feeling pissy.