Making the Band 4 (Male Supergroup) - Page 6

Mrs Cwebb · 07-31-2007, 03:17 AM

This is who I think will make the band:

Donnie, Robert, Willie, and Brian A (Qwanell can easily replace Donnie or Brian A's spot).

This season went by fast, but they also did 1 hr episodes as opposed to half hours. I also felt that while it started off relatively slow, the season picked up towards the end. Unfortunately, it was just too fast and I didn't really get to know any of the people except for Dan, Julius, and Donnie. I didn't even notice Robert's existence until tonight, which leads me to believe he's in the band. I believe he and maybe Willie, were the only ones that every single person on the judging panel picked to be in their band.

I feel so bad for Carlos, it must've been a lot of pain and stress for him to go through that and have to try out for the band. He always struck me as a good man and I wish him luck and happiness in his family.

Google · Sponsored Links

Johnsonator · 07-31-2007, 12:52 PM

Who got eliminated on the last episode?

biggbaddgirl · 07-31-2007, 01:04 PM

Carlos and Julius went home.

xoobrunettebabi · 07-31-2007, 04:06 PM

Finale next Monday!
What do you all think of the show?
I personally love it.
My top 4 would be :: Brian A., Qwannell, Robert and Donnie. My alternate two would be Willie and Dyshon.

kimrs · 07-31-2007, 04:29 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Mrs Cwebb

I didn't even notice Robert's existence until tonight, which leads me to believe he's in the band. I believe he and maybe Willie, were the only ones that every single person on the judging panel picked to be in their band.

I feel so bad for Carlos, it must've been a lot of pain and stress for him to go through that and have to try out for the band. He always struck me as a good man and I wish him luck and happiness in his family.

Robert is the one in Dan's group that was fighting with his girlfriend on the phone for one entire ep and so he kept refusing to practice with his group. Finally is the last scene he tells her off and they practice and sound great for Diddy.

I can't believe that there was no comment or offer of prayer by ANYONE in the judging panel for Carlos. There is no way that the production crew didn't tell them what was going on. I found that completely heartless.

My hopes for the band: Willie, Donnie, Dyshon, DeAngelo and Bryan A. Go with five Diddy! He always picks one more than he says he is going to.

fan*addict · 07-31-2007, 04:38 PM

I just don't get that Robert dude....I don't understand what the big draw is...
personally I don't care for him..
I liked Julius...and was sorry to see him go

as for my final four: Qwannell, Donnie, Willie, and Dyshon.

Brandongr3 · 07-31-2007, 11:14 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by kimrs

I can't believe that there was no comment or offer of prayer by ANYONE in the judging panel for Carlos. There is no way that the production crew didn't tell them what was going on. I found that completely heartless.

omg, I was saying the same thing.

I think the group might be Willie, Robert, Qwanell, Deangelo if 5 (which I hope it'll be 5) Donnie or Michael as the underdogs.

miadora · 07-31-2007, 11:27 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by fan*addict

I just don't get that Robert dude....I don't understand what the big draw is...
personally I don't care for him..
I liked Julius...and was sorry to see him go

as for my final four: Qwannell, Donnie, Willie, and Dyshon.

I just don't get the Brian A. and Robert love. They both always sound average at best. They're both too cocky for their talent and they are never considerate to others. Are they getting picked based on their image? Because that's all I see that they bring. I think "image" can be manufactured by anyone, singing ability can't. Can someone kindly explain their appeal? I don't get Donnie's appeal either. He can't dance, his singing is just okay. But I'm sure he'll happily accept the role of token white guy when he makes the group.

I'm glad Julius is gone. Is he sure his father is a preacher? That was some serious pouting, whining and negativity.

My four (mostly underdogs, of course, but hey, I was pissed when Dominique didn't make it in Making the Band 3):

DeAngelo
Brian H.
Jeremy
The overweight guy
and
Q if he picks a 5th member

Mrs Cwebb · 08-01-2007, 02:12 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by kimrs

Robert is the one in Dan's group that was fighting with his girlfriend on the phone for one entire ep and so he kept refusing to practice with his group. Finally is the last scene he tells her off and they practice and sound great for Diddy.

I must've missed that part coz I don't remember much of it all....that, or I simply have been half assed watching this season.

This band is going to be a bigger bomb than Da Band. Sad, because these group of guys are more likeable and grateful than Da Band. Is it me or does Robert sometimes look similar to Dylan from Da Band except without the face full of acne.

jacobson00 · 08-01-2007, 11:54 AM

the reason the band my bomb is because we barely know them, even after all these episodes.

07-31-2007, 03:17 AM	#51
Mrs Cwebb Thorpedo is Love Join Date: Apr 2004 Posts: 2,210	Re: Making the Band 4(Male Supergroup) This is who I think will make the band: Donnie, Robert, Willie, and Brian A (Qwanell can easily replace Donnie or Brian A's spot). This season went by fast, but they also did 1 hr episodes as opposed to half hours. I also felt that while it started off relatively slow, the season picked up towards the end. Unfortunately, it was just too fast and I didn't really get to know any of the people except for Dan, Julius, and Donnie. I didn't even notice Robert's existence until tonight, which leads me to believe he's in the band. I believe he and maybe Willie, were the only ones that every single person on the judging panel picked to be in their band. I feel so bad for Carlos, it must've been a lot of pain and stress for him to go through that and have to try out for the band. He always struck me as a good man and I wish him luck and happiness in his family.

07-31-2007, 12:52 PM	#52
Johnsonator FORT Fogey Join Date: Oct 2006 Location: Grayson Age: 17 Posts: 2,014	Re: Making the Band 4(Male Supergroup) Who got eliminated on the last episode?

07-31-2007, 01:04 PM	#53
biggbaddgirl Give Me A Hug Join Date: Sep 2003 Posts: 1,172	Re: Making the Band 4(Male Supergroup) Carlos and Julius went home.

07-31-2007, 04:06 PM	#54
xoobrunettebabi FORT Regular Join Date: Apr 2007 Location: tampa* Posts: 133	Making the Band 4 Finale next Monday! What do you all think of the show? I personally love it. My top 4 would be :: Brian A., Qwannell, Robert and Donnie. My alternate two would be Willie and Dyshon.

07-31-2007, 04:38 PM	#56
fan*addict FORT Fogey Join Date: Jul 2007 Location: Pittsburgh, PA Posts: 906	Re: Making the Band 4 I just don't get that Robert dude....I don't understand what the big draw is... personally I don't care for him.. I liked Julius...and was sorry to see him go as for my final four: Qwannell, Donnie, Willie, and Dyshon.

08-01-2007, 11:54 AM	#60
jacobson00 FORT Fogey Join Date: Feb 2004 Posts: 1,929	Re: Making the Band 4(Male Supergroup) the reason the band my bomb is because we barely know them, even after all these episodes.