I think it's hard to judge a show by the pilot episode. Sometimes you get a great pilot right off the bat (Glee for example) but lot's of shows take time to build. I think this one has a good cast and promising storylines. There is plenty of room for mystery, twists and surprises. It has some kinks to work out (see previous post about the FBI guy ), but all in all I think it should be good....provided it builds on the pilot, and doesn't devolve instead.