Harper's Island - Page 61

twochicklets · 07-01-2009, 12:59 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by misskitty

This has been one of the best non-reality shows on this season.....bloody scary!!!! Have to watch and yet don't want to watch. I love a great who-dunnit!!

=^.^=

It has greatly improved since they realized there were murders going on. Those first few episodes when people were disappearing and no one noticed bugged.

Google · Sponsored Links

Mike'sgirl · 07-01-2009, 07:05 PM

I don't think Danny is the killer, it looks like Shea and Madison may be able to get away on a speedboat (or not), Trish.... I think will be a goner soon, Abby - nah, so to me the most likely to be killer is among these: Henry, Jimmy or Sully.

Preview shows what looks like Danny and Sully fighting it out at the Sheirff's police station. I honestly don't know - would be surprised if the killer turns out to be Sully, (although he looks like he could be related to Wakefield - anyone know if his mother has a first name of Sarah?). Also surprised and very disappointed if it turns out to be Jimmy, and would be happy if it is Henry (only because I had him on my list since the beginning).

Twiddler · 07-02-2009, 01:00 AM

Wait....what preview? Linkage. I need to see this.

It means the killer is either Danny or Sully, right? Since they are fighting each other?

dixiegrl91 · 07-02-2009, 09:20 AM

My satellite guide said this was coming on Sat(4th) here in the US. So are we skipping a week or not? I don't rememeber what the episode title was.

lildago · 07-02-2009, 09:30 AM

Here's a side by side of Wakefield and Sully that someone posted on another site.

Amazing resemblance, no? Still, I'll be very surprised if it's him. Hard to believe he'd be talking to Danny about being guarded and wanting love If they get out of that mess if it's him. On the other hand, that could be the reason he spoke up and went with Cal....so he could ensure they never got the other boat. He could have untied it while Cal was unconscious. But then why even save Cal's life? Arrrgh! One could go crazy thinking all of this out. I'm still leaning towards Jimmy or Henry.

Twiddler · 07-02-2009, 01:26 PM

But Jimmy or Henry are too obvious, as killers! It's gotta be one of the others. I'm thinking either Sully, Danny, Shea, or Trish myself, though moreso Sully then the others.

Mike'sgirl · 07-02-2009, 01:27 PM

Quote:

Here's a side by side of Wakefield and Sully that someone posted on another site.

http://i16.photobucket.com/albums/b48/lildago/1z193tg.png

Amazing resemblance, no? Still, I'll be very surprised if it's him. Hard to believe he'd be talking to Danny about being guarded and wanting love If they get out of that mess if it's him. On the other hand, that could be the reason he spoke up and went with Cal....so he could ensure they never got the other boat. He could have untied it while Cal was unconscious. But then why even save Cal's life? Arrrgh! One could go crazy thinking all of this out. I'm still leaning towards Jimmy or Henry.

I agree, and am starting to just let it go - I will watch and enjoy! I thought some time ago there was a resemblance between them. Only thing I can think of for not killing Cal when he was upside down hanging, or when he dug out the bullet was because his papa (maybe) wanted to do the honors.

All I know is that they do plan to give us [[the back story as to why the killer is doing this, that they will be clear about motivation. Here is a little Karim Twitter: i'm satisfied with the way we unraveled & told the story, and with our choice for the killer ]]

Twiddler At episode 11 conclusion, they aired a preview and embedded within (if you looked frame by frame) you see Danny in the Sheriff's office and you see him suddenly try to slam a rifle into someone that looks like Sully from the back, but could be Wakefield I guess. I thought it was Sully because there is longer hair flying on the guy Danny is trying to hit (plus the frame is darkened and you only see rear and side of person he is fighting with). I watched it on DVR frame by frame - only way to catch it.

lildago · 07-02-2009, 04:52 PM

I snagged some photos from my Harper's Island group on Facebook. I can't get them to post in spoiler tags so if anyone is interested in seeing them, pm me. One thing I noticed....

[[
Danny isn't in any of the photos so my guess is he's a goner early in the show. Shae and Madison are also missing from the photos. ]]

Mike'sgirl · 07-02-2009, 06:38 PM

This is purely speculation, and I will probably be proven wrong but I think Shea and Madison will live and escape in the boat - a little repayment to Maddie for helping Wakefield out.
My intuition (ha) tells me Trish will die early in next episode 12, and Danny will die at the end of that episode because there are several SC of Danny with Sully, Henry and Abby, including one with Wakefield on the ground that need to play out still, possibly in the finale Ep13. That leaves Sully, Henry, Jimmy and Abby available to be the killer and since we will be surprised over it..... I think the killer will be Henry's old HS friend and best man Sully. Who does resemble Wakefield. I can find no information anywhere on Sully, well little bit at HG wiki but it doesn't tell me his mother's name. One of these, besides Abby must have a mother named Sarah. Or not,

It will be fun to watch the ending. To bad we don't have another murder mystery 2nd season!!!!

Please PM me those screencaps - I'd like to see them - thanks lildago!

Starbucks880 · 07-02-2009, 07:42 PM

Quote:

Here's a side by side of Wakefield and Sully that someone posted on another site.

http://i16.photobucket.com/albums/b48/lildago/1z193tg.png

Amazing resemblance, no? Still, I'll be very surprised if it's him. Hard to believe he'd be talking to Danny about being guarded and wanting love If they get out of that mess if it's him. On the other hand, that could be the reason he spoke up and went with Cal....so he could ensure they never got the other boat. He could have untied it while Cal was unconscious. But then why even save Cal's life? Arrrgh! One could go crazy thinking all of this out. I'm still leaning towards Jimmy or Henry.

Wow--they could be father and son, assuming the child of Wakefield has anything to do with who is the killer. I do think him making sure they never got to the boats is an interesting possibility. And we don't know what he was doing when cal was unconcious. maybe he needed Cal to be alive for a short time, so that the others would know that he saved his life and have their guard lowered around him--after all, who would expect the killer to save a life when everyone is being killed in twisted and creative ways around them? plus, after seeing him on One Tree Hill, I am naturally suspicious of him to begin with. But I am skeptical for the same reasons. I think Henry is more likely, though I would like it if it were Trish or Madison.

07-01-2009, 07:05 PM	#602
Mike'sgirl FORT Devotee Join Date: Apr 2003 Location: IA Posts: 4,918	Re: Harper's Island I don't think Danny is the killer, it looks like Shea and Madison may be able to get away on a speedboat (or not), Trish.... I think will be a goner soon, Abby - nah, so to me the most likely to be killer is among these: Henry, Jimmy or Sully. Preview shows what looks like Danny and Sully fighting it out at the Sheirff's police station. I honestly don't know - would be surprised if the killer turns out to be Sully, (although he looks like he could be related to Wakefield - anyone know if his mother has a first name of Sarah?). Also surprised and very disappointed if it turns out to be Jimmy, and would be happy if it is Henry (only because I had him on my list since the beginning). __________________ Hugo to Jack: "You and me, trekking through the jungle, on our way to do something we don't quite understand. Good times."

07-02-2009, 01:00 AM	#603
Twiddler Prophet of St. Hurley Join Date: Aug 2004 Posts: 343	Re: Harper's Island Wait....what preview? Linkage. I need to see this. It means the killer is either Danny or Sully, right? Since they are fighting each other?

07-02-2009, 09:20 AM	#604
dixiegrl91 FORT Fan Join Date: Jul 2008 Location: Somewhere Out There Age: 36 Posts: 184	Re: Harper's Island My satellite guide said this was coming on Sat(4th) here in the US. So are we skipping a week or not? I don't rememeber what the episode title was.

07-02-2009, 09:30 AM	#605
lildago Go Duke! Join Date: Feb 2004 Location: going mad Posts: 11,031	Re: Harper's Island Here's a side by side of Wakefield and Sully that someone posted on another site. Amazing resemblance, no? Still, I'll be very surprised if it's him. Hard to believe he'd be talking to Danny about being guarded and wanting love If they get out of that mess if it's him. On the other hand, that could be the reason he spoke up and went with Cal....so he could ensure they never got the other boat. He could have untied it while Cal was unconscious. But then why even save Cal's life? Arrrgh! One could go crazy thinking all of this out. I'm still leaning towards Jimmy or Henry. __________________ "I would wear him like a scrunchie."

07-02-2009, 01:26 PM	#606
Twiddler Prophet of St. Hurley Join Date: Aug 2004 Posts: 343	Re: Harper's Island But Jimmy or Henry are too obvious, as killers! It's gotta be one of the others. I'm thinking either Sully, Danny, Shea, or Trish myself, though moreso Sully then the others.

07-02-2009, 04:52 PM	#608
lildago Go Duke! Join Date: Feb 2004 Location: going mad Posts: 11,031	Re: Harper's Island I snagged some photos from my Harper's Island group on Facebook. I can't get them to post in spoiler tags so if anyone is interested in seeing them, pm me. One thing I noticed.... [[ Danny isn't in any of the photos so my guess is he's a goner early in the show. Shae and Madison are also missing from the photos. ]] __________________ "I would wear him like a scrunchie."

07-02-2009, 06:38 PM	#609
Mike'sgirl FORT Devotee Join Date: Apr 2003 Location: IA Posts: 4,918	Re: Harper's Island This is purely speculation, and I will probably be proven wrong but I think Shea and Madison will live and escape in the boat - a little repayment to Maddie for helping Wakefield out. My intuition (ha) tells me Trish will die early in next episode 12, and Danny will die at the end of that episode because there are several SC of Danny with Sully, Henry and Abby, including one with Wakefield on the ground that need to play out still, possibly in the finale Ep13. That leaves Sully, Henry, Jimmy and Abby available to be the killer and since we will be surprised over it..... I think the killer will be Henry's old HS friend and best man Sully. Who does resemble Wakefield. I can find no information anywhere on Sully, well little bit at HG wiki but it doesn't tell me his mother's name. One of these, besides Abby must have a mother named Sarah. Or not, It will be fun to watch the ending. To bad we don't have another murder mystery 2nd season!!!! Please PM me those screencaps - I'd like to see them - thanks lildago! __________________ Hugo to Jack: "You and me, trekking through the jungle, on our way to do something we don't quite understand. Good times."