Ok, so if we assume that Jacob has a child. I'd be more inclined to think it was none other than Ben. I got the impression that Jacob was testing
Ben by acting as if he didn't give a freak about him and letting him know of the choice he had, by giving him a tumor, by saving his life when he was a kid, etc... Jacob been seen going back/forth to civilization at different periods of time, what's to say he didn't knock up Emily.
I was also thinking about the fact that *Bob* referenced that he can't kill Jacob. Maybe his son could though
. I think when Ben exits the foot and Richard becomes aware of Ben "killing" Jacob, Richard will know something that the rest don't know. hmmm
I still am not even 100% convinced that *Bob* and Smokey are the same... If this is the case that would mean Christian that we've seen visit Jack in the hospital, visit Michael on the freighter was all Smokey
I don't know, there are a bunch of problems with the story and i am confusing myself