I liked this show. I haven't seen Cashmere Mafia. Although Lipstick wasn't great, SATC didn't start out great either. There was a lot of personalizing to the camera that I wasn't digging. I'll give this show more time to gel. Brooke was looking pretty old compared to the other two. I loved seeing Andrew McCarthy on there. Had a crush on him when I was younger. I liked the storyline of him a little bit. I think Kim Raver did great with her role. Very believable.