I for one cannot wait to see her go.
I think Paris is entertaining, then Kellie, then Katherine. I think she and Ace suffer from after-audition low-glow (invented that term), meaning they were fine on the small audition stage, but then some aspects of a large stage swallows them up. Nerves for Ace, less energy for Kat, etc. Kellie, Paris, and Taylor seemed to have made the shift most successfully imo.
Why is it boys talk so much, when they have nothing to say? And girls have plenty to say, but no one will listen?
I don't think Kellie is desparately trying to portray herself as sweet or innocent - or anything, really. Comparatively, to the other contestants who are somewhat more reserved or "sophisticated" in a sense (I don't mean that Kellie isn't dignified) - Kellie really just puts it all out there and behaves the way she would without all the cameras around. Perhaps her naiveity (sp?) comes off as fake to people, but for me, she's the real deal.
Last edited by Tickety; 04-17-2006 at 07:57 AM.
Ok, I am not a Kellie fan.
These are the three reasons why.
1. Vocal talent: She has one of the weakest two voices left (Ace being the other).
2. Stage Performance: She doesn't command the stage. It is very easy to take my eyes off of her. She doesn't make me excited to see what she is going to do next. I can't see anything in her that make me say "wow" that girl is the American Idol.
3. Personality: Finally, I do not like the way she is when the music is over. Her constant attention seeking comments and behavior are extremely annoying. I don't care if it's real or false, at this point I just want her to stop.
Honestly, I have not seen any one competitor this year that has all three of the components I would like to see from the AI winner. Some have one of the three, some even have two of the three, but Kellie doesn't have any of the three.
You "hit the nail on the head".
"Show a dog an ounce of love and he'll be your friend for life." ~ Stuart and Linda Macfarlane
I actually think Kellie will be in the bottom 3 tomorrow. That performance was too bad for her not to be. She'll still be safe, though.