I watched SF for the first time a short time ago, and I didn't think Puck was as bad as he was hyped up to be. Annoying, yes, but I don't think he was threatening. And frankly, I thought it was greedy of Pedro to kick him out. But I digress.
Then the first season of Battle of the Sexes came along. What a great season of The RW/RR Challenge, and I still long for the day when MTV will bring out challenges like that again. Anyway, he was freakin' nuts on that challenge! And scary. Didn't he have a machete at one point? His true colors showed.
Thanks for the info, Juls! It's so true, what would we do without Wikipedia? I looked through that page before, but I missed the part about people who had left and was a little bit lazy to look back. Hm, I guess Trisha wasn't the first girl who was asked to leave. And I gotta say, the description of Erika makes it sound very dramatic and interesting, with the whole "possible depression" thing.