ok, Just came home from watching this movie (actually saw both Shrek and Troy this evening) and here's my two cents worth. I'll try to be as brief as I can.
Plot was good, acting was good (I usually hate fighting scenes, but they were ok) The movie didn't really need the semi-nude scenes with Brad Pitt, but that didn't bother me
ORlando BLoom's character = moron, idiot, jerk, coward (I have no idea how many times me and my friend kept saying that)
"You think I'm a coward don't you" ... me and my friend out loud in the theater "YES"
I won't spoil it to others who haven't seen it yet.
Overall my rating 8.5 out of 10.
I wasn't expecting much from this movie, but found it actually really good! Thumbs up