Oh brother on the Walmart product placement ad!!
But, here's the thing: don't they say that they are being judged on that dish only when there is an elimination? Or , do they say it has to do with their entire performance? Because, there was only one dish that the judge spit out and said was inedible. If it was judged solely on that performance, she would have been the obvious one to leave. So, the judges are looking at past performance, and probably who keeps some drama going, when they eliminate someone. An average nice guy doesn't have a chance in that case.