Brooke's Not the Only One who wants to throw up . .
Given that a "right" decision was impossible in this instance, and the best that they could do was only choose the less bad of two possible outcomes---Yeah, I think they minimized the carnage as much as they could.
I thought the way they broke the news to Suzanne was really crappy--They blatantly lied to the women by telling them that only one of them would be coming back to the house in a limo. So when Suzanne was brought back to the house, she naturally assumed that she had been chosen. At least on the Bachelor, when they do that, both candidates are aware that they have an equal chance of being shot down. Marty obviously didn't know beforehand--that crestfallen look on his Botoxed face--it fell as much as his paralyzed nerves will allow it--when Suzanne came out was like a neon sign. Then they continued that falsehood by giving her a frilly 5 minute speech before kicking her to the curb. That stunned look on her face spoke volumes, and I thought she held it together admirably. Had it been me, I would've heaved all over Marty's shiny tuxedo.
Yeah . . .here's my scenario: Marty and Stacy have been separated since the end of taping, so they still have the hots for one another. As soon as they do the round of talk shows, they'll go on a Caribbean trip and get it on every way til Tuesday. After they've gotten it out of their systems, ie, returned to his reality of delivering Fritos in Denver, they will realize that they have absolutely nothing in common as the basis for a marriage, and will split up. Personally I don't think Stacy will go through with a wedding--that reaction of hers last night looked more like "Oh, my God--what do I do NOW??' than "Oh, my God, I'm so happy!" If they do have a quickie wedding ceremony, Stacy will have fewer qualms about annulling the whole silly charade than Suzanne would've done. Heck, she may even find Marty's replacement while they are still on their Caribbean 'honeymoon'. Suzanne more likely wanted a real marriage, and would have been far unhappier in the long run with this Stepford bogus-husband than Stacy will.
So, the girls did as well as they could--they gave their arrested development-horndog father his immediate gratification & allowed Suzanne to keep her dignity in the long term. Having to dismantle a sham marriage would have hurt her a lot more than either Stacy or Marty . . .after a few months (if that long) they will return to their pre-show lives, and perhaps Suzanne will find a REAL man from her scads of admirers.
Best of luck to Suzanne. I don't give a hang what happens to our two lovebirds--they deserve each other.