I'm one of the few who likes Tate's looks - probably the extra eyelashes. But as a person he is gawdawful - immature, annoying, stupid.
Maurice and Hunter look good in photos, but in real life their lips seem too feminine to me.
Paulo looks good, but he would be an absolute pain to work with given his control issues and I think that's the only reason he got dropped.
I liked Jason in person, but he never seemed to look in his pictures like he looked when he was animated.
As for Kevin P - I hate him.