Interesting show. I was surprised when they mentioned it was on last week, because I completely missed it... probably due to the Heroes season finale. But I wasn't terribly lost even though I missed a week.
A concern I have is that the judges might be a little too old to understand some of the entries from the younger contestants. They didn't seem to like some of the shorts that I found hilarious. But that might be from differences in people's senses of humors.
I liked "Lucky Penny" and the Lightbulb one and "Dance Man" and "Check Out." And I didn't find "Getta Rhoom" as offensive as the judges did. I actually agreed with the audience (who seemed to be booing the judges) that it was very funny.
And does anyone else think Marty is a complete tool? He didn't do the challenge. Everyone else did a story with a beginning, middle and end. He just threw a bunch of cool scenes together (which reminds me of Mark Borchardt). He definately has filmmaking skills, but he needs to commit to doing a complete story.