I love, love, love Eternity and, last I checked, it really smelled good on me. When I switch scents, I usually stay with the new one for years. Liz, I wouldn't worry what MEN liked. I think as long as YOU like/love the way a scent smells on you, it will work for whomever is around you. If it doesn't, I say a great scent also can chase the goonies away....male OR female! I used to wear a male scent (Aramis) in high school; girls and guys LOVED it. There was another male scent I would wear that the guys really liked. I just happened to run across these bottles, and the price was right....free!! I got excellent use out of them! Thanks to whomever didn't want them!