Traditional Virgo Traits
Modest and shy --> modest? not sure. unassuming maybe. shy? no.
Meticulous and reliable --> yes.
Practical and diligent --> yes, but only when necessary.
Intelligent and analytical --> definitely analytical.
On the dark side....
Fussy and a worrier --> fussy, yes. worrier, no.
Overcritical and harsh --> not really. i like critiquing, but tend to have a kind approach.
Perfectionist and conservative --> perfectionist, yes. conservative? nope.
I somewhat adequately fit the above, but not perfectly. I feel more kinship with the descriptions for Scorpio.