Im giving it away but I do have a cousin named Guido and he shares that name with both his dad and his son.
I'd say # 1 is the lie, ECM.
My guess is that #2 is the lie.
CMD and Bunny are both correct.
1. I can see the lake from the porch of my house.
2. I used to travel by Amtrak a lot.
3. At a cook-out, I prefer a burger to a hot dog.
I'm really horrible at this game, but I'm guessing #2.
Count your blessings!