American Idol All-Stars Game!

[TerryBo2k]

i think the list is small enough to have people update after each post. so go ahead and do so if you feel like it

after we find the winner for AI3, then those winners will go head-to-head. should we reset their points to '20'? or should we have them keep their original points?

[AIWANNABE]

I voted after BHanson's NEW DAY post. So the scores need to be redone since I am NOT the only person who voted twice in the same day.

Bhanson doesn't live in EST, so 1:57 AM is still Tuesday for him. He then voted on a NEW day, Wednesday, therefore not breaking the rule of voting twice in the same day.

after we find the winner for AI3, then those winners will go head-to-head. should we reset their points to '20'? or should we have them keep their original points?

I'd reset them to 20, but that's just my opinion.

[bhanson]

Bhanson doesn't live in EST, so 1:57 AM is still Tuesday for him. He then voted on a NEW day, Wednesday, therefore not breaking the rule of voting twice in the same day. .

Yes, AIWANNABE is correct about that. Im really glad that Trenyce and Vonzell won their seasons. If only that was how it played out in real life

[ev700]

+1 Latoya -2 Amy

AI 1:
Kelly Clarkson-31
AI 2:
Trenyce-22
AI 3:
Jennifer Hudson-10
La Toya London-15
AI 4:
Vonzell Solomon-25

[bhanson]

+1 Latoya -2 Jennifer

AI 1:
Kelly Clarkson-31
AI 2:
Trenyce-22
AI 3:
Jennifer Hudson-8
La Toya London-16
AI 4:
Vonzell Solomon-25

[AIWANNABE]

+Jennifer -LaToya

AI 1:
Kelly Clarkson-31
AI 2:
Trenyce-22
AI 3:
Jennifer Hudson-9
La Toya London-14
AI 4:
Vonzell Solomon-25

[Aota Bass]

Can't we just have LaToya and Jennifer showdown against each other in the finals? I wish that's how it had actually played out.

Oh well...

LaToya +, Jennifer -

AI 1:
Kelly Clarkson-31
AI 2:
Trenyce-22
AI 3:
Jennifer Hudson-7
La Toya London-16
AI 4:
Vonzell Solomon-25

And Terry, whatever you decide as far as showdown scores go is cool by me, but I'd rather see them reset, since Kelly got the highest number of points largely due to the lack of competition in her season (not that she didn't deserve them- but I don't think it's an accurate reflection points-wise of how she compares to the other winners on the list).

[~Lurker~]

+1 La Toya -2 Jennifer

AI 1:
Kelly Clarkson-31
AI 2:
Trenyce-22
AI 3:
Jennifer Hudson-5
La Toya London-17
AI 4:
Vonzell Solomon-25

[RubenIZMyne]

+1 La Toya -2 Jennifer

AI 1:
Kelly Clarkson-31
AI 2:
Trenyce-22
AI 3:
Jennifer Hudson-3
La Toya London-18
AI 4:
Vonzell Solomon-25

[TerryBo2k]

And Terry, whatever you decide as far as showdown scores go is cool by me, but I'd rather see them reset, since Kelly got the highest number of points largely due to the lack of competition in her season (not that she didn't deserve them- but I don't think it's an accurate reflection points-wise of how she compares to the other winners on the list).

I think I'll reset the scores to 20. That seems like a pretty good number

Here's my vote:
+1 La Toya -2 Jennifer

AI 1:
Kelly Clarkson-31
AI 2:
Trenyce-22
AI 3:
Jennifer Hudson-1
La Toya London-19
AI 4:
Vonzell Solomon-25