I Prefer..

pink
I prefer bananas to honeydew melon.

bananas

I prefer banana bread to blueberry bread.

banana bread
I prefer Peter Pan to Jif.

Jif, but I grew up eating Peter Pan :nod

I prefer smooth pb over chunky.

smooth

I prefer dark mustard to bright yellow.

bright yellow
I prefer chicken breast meat to thigh meat.

chicken breast meat

I prefer The Beatles to The Rolling Stones.

Beatles
I prefer Paul McCartney's voice to Ringo's.

Paul McCartney

I prefer a vacation at the beach versus skiing in the mountains.

vacation at the beach :)

I prefer liquid laundry detergent to powdered.