I Prefer..

Movie popcorn

I prefer staying in at night to going out.

staying in at home
I prefer plastic cups to glasses.

Glasses

I prefer oval tables to square.

I like square ones.
I prefer listening to music to watching movies.

Me too.

I prefer modern decor to vintage.

modern
I prefer butter pecan ice cream to strawberry.

butter pecan (and can I go back and change all of my other answers now that I know how to play this game?)

I prefer giving gifts to getting gifts.

giving
I prefer a tuna sandwich to bologna.

I like both the same.

I prefer straw laundry baskets to plastic.

:hiya nana!!
I like the plastic baskets.
I prefer romance books to sci-fi.